Project Funder: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
Project Partners: Lead and Environmental Hazards Association (LEHA)
Project Contact: Jonathan Wilson, jwilson@nchh.org, 443.539.4162.
What we studied: The main objective was to understand better the relative risks of deteriorated lead paint among various building components and room types, particularly doors and windows, in older affordable housing.
Why it matters: Thousands of lead-based paint inspections and risk assessments have been completed by professionals in recent years, but they have not yet been assembled into a suitable database to support a housing surveillance system. This study determined whether a large, high-quality housing lead hazard surveillance database can be assembled to investigate pressing questions about the relationships among the presence of lead-based paint, its concentration and condition, and dust lead levels.
Project Description
The CLEARS study uploaded results of thousands of lead-based paint risk assessments, inspections, and evaluations of homes of children with elevated blood lead levels to support the creation of a lead-based paint housing surveillance system.
Working with local private and public lead poisoning prevention professionals and laboratories, along with the Lead and Environmental Hazards Association, data from 2,128 pre-1978 dwelling units—comprising 350,104 interior and 45,685 exterior XRF measurements, 12,619 floor dust lead measurements, 8,772 windowsill dust lead measurements, and other variables—were assembled and statistically analyzed.
When nationally representative lead paint housing datasets have been created, such as the American Healthy Homes Surveys, the survey protocols were limited to a subset of the rooms in each dwelling due to feasibility, cost, and other constraints. This new study used a much larger set of existing data collected according to HUD/EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) requirements, so that in all dwellings, all unique building components (testing combinations) in all room equivalents were measured. The resulting dataset was called CLEARS (Creating a Lead Evaluation and Assessment Reporting System).
Special treatment of dust lead results that were below laboratory reporting limits improved the ability to meet the study objective. Such results were replaced by the raw, uncensored “machine” value derived from the lab analytical instrument absorbance or other output and the associated laboratory calibration curve. The “machine” values are likely closer to the true value, although there is more uncertainty. Laboratories do not typically report machine values to clients because of this increased uncertainty and due to accepted practices, but they did agree to provide them to the study team for the purpose of statistical analysis.
Results
Although all reports complied with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) guidelines, their report formats varied widely. The percentage of homes with any interior lead paint was 62% (28%–88%), depending on risk categorization: that is, homes without or with children with elevated blood lead levels. The percentage of homes with exterior lead paint was 63% (28%–88%). The percentage with both interior and exterior lead paint was 51% (8%–86%).
Room names, room number, and building component naming systems were highly variable among different inspection firms, making data cleaning needlessly complex. The formats of existing lead evaluation data obtained from local inspection and risk assessment professionals are not consistent and are not currently amenable to routine import into a national housing surveillance database. At the same time, all reports from local professionals substantially complied with existing laws, regulations, and guidelines.
Conclusions
Increased standardization of lead-based paint report formats, including standardized room, building component, and surface nomenclature, is needed to create a national housing surveillance system. All current commercially available XRF portable lead paint analyzers can download data into electronic files, making handwritten data obsolete. Most labs can now provide electronic files with dust and soil data. Improved standardization would help optimal targeting of remediation and future research to ensure children are adequately protected. Such standardization could be accomplished by a revised edition of the HUD lead paint guidelines and/or other consensus standard-setting organization.
Resources
Dixon, S. L., Wilson, J., Jacobs, D. E., & Breysse, J.(2026, March/April). Challenges of importing residential lead paint inspection and risk assessment reports into a national database. Journal of Public Health Management & Practice, 32(2): 253–259. | DOI: 10.1097/PHH.0000000000002315.
Latest page update: October 16, 2026.